At The Arndt Law Firm, we understand that a car accident can change your life in an instant. Our team is dedicated to guiding you through the complexities of the legal process and providing the support you need during this challenging time. We know that navigating the aftermath of an accident involves more than just legal matters; it impacts your well-being, your family, and your daily routine.
We take pride in offering compassionate representation tailored to your unique situation. Our experienced attorneys will take the time to listen to your story, understand your concerns, and collaborate with you to develop a strategy that addresses your needs. We believe in empowering our clients, ensuring that you feel confident and informed throughout the journey.
Your healing and peace of mind are our top priorities. Our team will work diligently to alleviate the stress and uncertainties that often accompany car accidents. We’re here to stand by your side, advocating for you every step of the way.
If you or a loved one has been involved in a car accident, please reach out to us. Let’s discuss your situation and explore your options together. Contact us today to schedule a consultation, and allow us to help you take the first step toward recovery.
Most people treat the report as the verdict. Section 56-5-1290 says otherwise: none of the accident reports required of drivers and owners may be evidence of the negligence or due care of either party at the trial of an action for damages. Officers may refer to their reports when testifying, but only to refresh recollection.
That cuts both ways, and it usually helps an injured driver. A narrative that reads badly, a diagram drawn from a brief look at the scene, or an officer's impression recorded an hour later does not settle liability. It can be answered with measurements, damage geometry, and witness accounts the officer never had.
Two reporting duties sit alongside it. Section 56-5-1260 requires a driver involved in a crash causing injury or death to give immediate notice by the quickest means to the local police department if it happened inside a municipality, and otherwise to the county sheriff or the nearest Highway Patrol office. Section 56-5-1270 requires the operator or owner to file a written report within fifteen days when the crash caused injury, death, or apparent property damage of $1,000 or more and was not investigated by an officer.
Is the police report proof of who caused the crash?
No. Under Section 56-5-1290, the reports drivers and owners must file are not admissible as evidence of negligence or due care at trial. The report is the starting document, and fault is established from physical evidence and testimony.
Horry County has more responding agencies along a single corridor than most South Carolina markets, and sending a request to the wrong one returns nothing.
Myrtle Beach Police Department investigates inside Myrtle Beach city limits. North Myrtle Beach Police Department is a separate department covering that city. The South Carolina Highway Patrol investigates on the highways and throughout the unincorporated county. Horry County Fire Rescue responds to crashes across the county and generates its own run reports. The Horry County Coroner's Office maintains a separate file for each fatality, including the cause of death.
Published crash reports show all of these occurring on the same road. A collision on Highway 17 Bypass near Harbour Towne Drive prompted Horry County Fire Rescue, with the Highway Patrol investigating and Myrtle Beach police assisting. A crash at the Highway 17 Bypass and Highway 501 junction was handled by Myrtle Beach police. North Myrtle Beach police investigated a pedestrian fatality on Old Highway 17 North.
The fire rescue run report deserves particular attention. It frequently contains the earliest clinical description of an injured person's condition, recorded before any insurer was involved, which becomes valuable when a carrier later argues the injury developed from something else.
US 17 Bypass carries the heaviest recurring collision pattern in the market. Published incidents place serious crashes at its junction with US 501, near 38th Avenue North, near Harbor Towne Drive, and at Deerfield Links Drive, including a four-vehicle collision and an overturn that blocked the northbound lanes.
Kings Highway produces a different pattern in the oceanfront blocks, which are addressed by numbered avenues. A fatal hit-and-run near the 1000 block of South Kings Highway closed the road from 9th Avenue South to 13th Avenue South during the investigation.
Highway 9, north of North Myrtle Beach, has seen fatal single-vehicle collisions, including a motorcycle striking a ramp guardrail. Juniper Bay Road in the county has had fatal single-vehicle crashes investigated by the Highway Patrol.
Those are different roads producing different collision types, and the evidence that matters differs with them. A multi-vehicle chain on a bypass is reconstructed from damage sequencing. A pedestrian strike on an oceanfront block turns on sight lines and lighting. A single vehicle crash into a guardrail raises questions about the roadway itself.
The South Carolina Department of Public Safety recorded 2,842 collisions producing injuries other than serious ones in Horry County during the fiscal year ending September 30, 2024, alongside 169 serious injury collisions and 60 fatal ones, out of 11,004 collisions in total.
That distribution describes the claims most people actually bring. The great majority of injured drivers here are not catastrophically hurt. They have a neck or back injury, a course of treatment, time away from work, and a vehicle to replace. Those files move through a high-volume process, and the process is built for speed rather than accuracy.
Over five years, the county recorded 54,154 collisions, with people aged 25 to 34 accounting for the largest share of deaths and serious injuries, with 74 killed. That is the age band where an injury affects earning capacity for decades, and where an early offer built on medical bills alone understates the loss most severely.
Value is assembled from categories rather than a multiplier. The economic side is documented: emergency treatment, imaging, follow-up care, physical therapy, prescriptions, mileage to appointments, and any future care a physician says is likely. Lost income belongs here, and so does lost earning capacity where an injury changes what a person can do for a living.
The noneconomic side covers pain, disfigurement, and the loss of things a person used to do. There is no general statutory cap on noneconomic damages in an ordinary South Carolina crash case; the noneconomic cap people read about is the medical malpractice cap, and it does not travel to a collision.
One exception matters here: if the defendant is a governmental entity, a county or state vehicle, or a municipal driver, the Tort Claims Act caps recovery at $300,000 per person and $600,000 per occurrence under Section 15-78-120, and bars punitive damages and prejudgment interest.
Two factors move the number in this county specifically. The first is the working profile of the people most often hurt: state data over five years shows drivers aged 25 to 34 accounting for the largest share of deaths and serious injuries, with the 35 to 44 band close behind. Those are the ages where an injury affects earning capacity for decades and where an offer built on medical bills alone understates the loss most severely.
The second is where treatment happened. A resident treated at Grand Strand Regional Medical Center and followed up locally produces a clean single-state record. A visitor treated here and followed up at home produces a record split across two states, and reconciling it is work an adjuster will not do on the claimant's behalf.
Property damage is settled separately and earlier, and the two should be kept apart. An adjuster who resolves the vehicle claim quickly has not valued the injury claim, and a release signed for one should never release the other.
Does South Carolina limit pain and suffering damages after a crash?
No. There is no general statutory cap on noneconomic damages in an ordinary South Carolina injury case. However, if the defendant is a governmental entity, the Tort Claims Act imposes a cap of $300,000 per person and $600,000 per occurrence, and bars punitive damages and prejudgment interest; the cap that exists for medical malpractice does not apply to typical crash claims.
South Carolina lets an injured driver recover as long as their share of the fault is not greater than the other driver's, with the award reduced by that percentage and barred entirely at 51 percent. The rule comes from Nelson v. Concrete Supply Co., a 1991 South Carolina Supreme Court decision rather than a statute.
The arithmetic is unforgiving at the margin, and the adjuster knows it. The officer does not assign percentages at the scene. They are argued from vehicle positions, damage patterns, sight lines, signal timing, scene measurements, and witness accounts, which is precisely why the report's inadmissibility matters less than people fear and the physical evidence matters more.
Since January 1, 2026, a further rule applies to claims accruing after that date. A defendant may ask that a party who was never sued be placed on the verdict form and assigned a share, provided that party is disclosed within one hundred eighty days of the start of the action and the defendant proves their breach was a proximate cause. On a four-vehicle collision, that mechanism has obvious appeal to a defendant, which is a reason to identify everyone involved at the outset. The Myrtle Beach injury analysis covers how it operates.
Who decides fault after a South Carolina crash?
Ultimately, a jury, or the parties in settlement negotiations anticipating what a jury would do. The officer's opinion and any citation are evidence rather than a determination, and the report itself is not admissible to prove negligence.
Horry County claims regularly involve people insured somewhere other than South Carolina. The Horry County Coroner's Office has identified crash victims from other states, including a rider from Kansas killed on Highway 9.
That changes the coverage question rather than the liability one. South Carolina law governs a crash that happened in South Carolina, including the three-year deadline and the comparative fault rule. What the other driver's policy actually provides is governed by the policy, which may have been written under another state's requirements and may carry different limits, different definitions, and different exclusions.
The practical consequence is that a coverage position letter from an out-of-state carrier is read rather than accepted. So is the claimant's own policy, where an injured visitor may have coverage from home that responds to a crash here.
South Carolina requires liability coverage of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident, plus $25,000 for property damage. Uninsured motorist coverage is mandatory at the same limits and responds where the at-fault driver has no insurance or leaves the scene, which matters in a market that has produced fatal hit-and-run collisions.
Underinsured motorist coverage, which pays when the at-fault policy is too small for the loss, is optional. It carries a rule worth checking on every claim: an insurer must hold a signed form showing that the coverage was offered and either accepted or rejected. Where the carrier cannot produce that form, it must add the coverage and rate for it.
Section 38-77-350 governs the offer form: a form signed by the named insured creates a conclusive presumption that the selection was informed and knowing. Under subsection (E), if the insured never returns an executed form within thirty days, the insurer must add uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage at the insured's liability limits.
Whether a carrier made a meaningful offer is worth examining on every UIM claim.
Order of recovery matters. The at-fault liability policy comes first. Underinsured coverage sits above it and responds to the shortfall.
South Carolina limits stacking. Under Section 38-77-160, where an insured carries uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage above the basic limits, the policy must provide that the insured is protected only to the extent of the coverage on the vehicle involved in the accident. If none of the insured's vehicles was involved, coverage is available only to the extent of coverage on any one of those vehicles.
The practical question in a household with several policies is therefore which vehicle was involved and what that policy carries, not how many policies exist.
| Source | When it responds | What to establish |
|---|---|---|
| At-fault driver's liability policy | Always first | Limits, and any exclusion asserted |
| Your uninsured motorist coverage | Other driver uninsured or fled | Required in SC at minimum limits |
| Your underinsured motorist coverage | At-fault policy too small | Whether the carrier holds a signed rejection form |
| An out-of-state policy | Visiting driver at fault | What that policy actually provides, read rather than assumed |
An impaired driving crash is the same negligence claim with two differences that change its value. The first is a possible second defendant, since a licensed establishment that knowingly served an intoxicated person can face liability. Since January 1, 2026, a licensee found liable alongside a charged driver is jointly and severally liable for fifty percent of the plaintiff's actual damages.
That claim carries a real burden rather than following automatically from the crash. The statute requires that the licensee sold knowingly to a person in an intoxicated condition, which means proving both the service and the licensee's knowledge of the person's condition at the time, usually from point-of-sale records, server accounts, and surveillance footage. It is a claim worth investigating in every case, and it is not a claim that succeeds simply because a driver had been drinking.
The second is punitive damages. South Carolina caps them at the greater of three times the compensatory award or a statutory figure adjusted annually. She removes that cap entirely where the defendant acted while under the influence of alcohol or drugs to the degree that judgment was substantially impaired. That is the most favorable provision available in these cases, and it is routinely omitted by pages that cite the cap and stop. The drunk driving analysis covers how the two claims fit together.
The criminal case runs on its own track. A conviction is useful evidence and is not required for the civil claim to succeed.
South Carolina gives an injured driver three years from the date of the crash to file suit under Section 15-3-530(5). Where an injury was not apparent at the time, the same three years runs from when the person knew or reasonably should have known a claim existed.
A claim against a governmental entity must be brought within two years of the date the loss was or should have been discovered. That becomes three years only if the claimant first files a verified claim with the agency or political subdivision, and that claim is received within one year of the same discovery date. Filing the verified claim is optional; missing the one-year window does not bar the case; it leaves the two-year deadline in place.
Keep in mind that South Carolina immunizes highway design outright: under Section 15-78-60(15), a governmental entity is not liable for the design of highways and other public ways, and it is not liable for failing to place a sign, signal, guardrail, or median barrier in the first instance where that was a discretionary act.
A crash on the job produces two claims: workers' compensation against the employer, and a third-party claim against the at-fault driver, which is governed by the ordinary three-year deadline. Section 42-1-560(b) separately directs that the third-party action be commenced within one year after the carrier accepts liability or pays under an award.
Missing that year does not end the claim; under subsection (c), it lets the carrier take the action by assignment, and only after twenty days' written notice, with the claim reassigned back if the carrier does not pursue it. It is still the date to treat as the working deadline.
Children, however, get a longer period of time, since the period is tolled during minority, though it cannot extend more than one year past the eighteenth birthday.
The evidence clock is shorter than any of these. Scene conditions change within days, and privately held camera footage runs on retention cycles measured in weeks.
A suit is filed in the Court of Common Pleas for Horry County, in the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit. The courthouse is at 1301 Second Avenue in Conway, with the Clerk of Court reachable at (843) 915-5080 and a second clerk's office at 9630 Scipio Lane in Myrtle Beach at (843) 915-5082.
Conway is the county seat while Myrtle Beach is the largest community, so the courthouse sits away from where most claims arise. The Myrtle Beach Magistrate Court at 1201 21st Avenue North handles small claims and traffic rather than injury suits.
Seriously injured people are transported to Grand Strand Regional Medical Center in Myrtle Beach. Treatment in the same city helps a claim, since the record comes from one in-state institution rather than across a state line.
Two moves recur in South Carolina auto claims, and both are legitimate insurance practice rather than misconduct. Understanding them is most of the defense.
The first is the recorded statement, requested early while an injured person is medicated, tired, and inclined to be agreeable. Questions about how the crash happened invite speculation, and questions about how someone feels invite the answer "fine," which is what people say reflexively.
Both answers are quoted back months later. There is no obligation to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer.
The second is the treatment gap. An injured person waits a week because the pain seems like it will pass, or misses appointments around work and childcare, and the adjuster reads the calendar rather than the injury. The answer is a documented explanation given at the time rather than reconstructed afterward.
Both land harder on someone whose work does not stop and on a visitor who leaves the state before follow-up care begins.
Do I have to give the other driver's insurer a recorded statement?
No. There is no obligation to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance company. Your own policy may require cooperation with your own insurer, which is a separate and narrower question.
Three years from the date of the crash under S.C. Code Section 15-3-530(5). Government defendants and workers' compensation third-party claims run shorter.
Section 56-5-1270 requires the operator or owner to file within fifteen days when there was injury, death, or apparent property damage of $1,000 or more and no officer investigated the crash.
South Carolina law governs a crash that happened here. What their policy provides is governed by that policy, which may have been written to another state's requirements.
Uninsured motorist coverage is required in South Carolina and can respond when the at-fault driver is never identified. However, Section 38-77-170 sets three conditions, and all three must be met. First, the accident must be reported to an appropriate police authority within a reasonable time. Second, there must be either physical contact with the unknown vehicle, an independent witness other than the owner or operator of the insured vehicle who signs an affidavit (or is deposed before suit under Rule 27), or a recording of the accident. Third, the insured must not have been negligent in failing to identify the other vehicle and driver at the scene. The witness affidavit requirement is why names and phone numbers taken at the scene decide these claims.
Nothing up front. Consultations are free, and the fee is contingent on recovery.
The Arndt Law Firm starts a Horry County crash claim by establishing which agency holds the file, because a request sent to the wrong department returns nothing and the delay costs weeks. Myrtle Beach, North Myrtle Beach, the Highway Patrol, county fire rescue, and the coroner all maintain separate records, and several of them may exist for one collision.
From there, the work is the physical evidence, since the report itself cannot be used at trial to prove negligence and the fault percentage will be argued from measurements rather than narrative. Horry County claims are filed in the Court of Common Pleas in Conway. Attorney Jonathan S. Arndt has been licensed in South Carolina since 2018 and reviews the firm's collision matters.
No fee is charged unless the claim recovers, and the first conversation is free of charge. You can reach the firm through the contact page. Camera footage along the bypass corridor is commonly overwritten within weeks, long before the three-year deadline becomes the operative constraint.
Last reviewed: August 2026
This page was reviewed by Jonathan S. Arndt, licensed in South Carolina since 2018.
Content is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a licensed South Carolina attorney for guidance specific to your situation.
